What’s the Best Roof for a House?

A Close Look at Brown, Newly Installed Shingles

How to Choose With So Many Options

Thousands and thousands of homes across the state rely on asphalt roof shingles for their daily protection. Low material costs and moderate durability make shingles a lucrative choice for most homeowners. Can homeowners do better? Yes. Is it worth the extra expense? Let’s find out!

Today, we’ll go over many of the asphalt roof shingles pros and cons. Afterwards, we’ll discuss potential alternatives and what they have to offer. By the end, you should have a clear picture of which solutions might fit your needs.

Choosing a Shingle Solution

Many homeowners never look beyond asphalt shingles, but there are countless possibilities when it comes to residential roofing. Your budget will play a prominent role in your selection process of course, but you should examine durability, longevity, and maintenance requirements as well.

Below, we’ll assess basic asphalt solutions and compare them with other solutions within the shingle category.

Pros & Cons

A Fair Assessment of Asphalt Shingles

Let’s be honest. When people ask “What type of roof lasts the longest?“, no one is going to jump up and shout “Asphalt shingles!” With a fairly short lifetime of up to 20 years, these roofing materials aren’t breaking any records. Frankly, they don’t need to.

Most homeowners choose asphalt shingles for their affordability and familiarity. Asphalt roof shingles cost a mere $80 – $100 (on average).They offer fairly capable protection against the majority of roofing hazards, and they’re easy to replace in the event of catastrophic damage. That pretty much sums up the benefits of asphalt shingles.

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles

  • Pro: Light to Moderate Weather Protection
  • Pro: Light to Moderate Pest Defense
  • Pro: High Affordability
  • Pro: Cheap Maintenance Costs
  • Pro: Extreme Product Variety
  • Con: Moderate to Frequent Repair Needs
  • Con: Short Lifespan
  • Con: Low Energy Efficiency

Enhanced Shingles

What is the Best Type of Roof Shingles?

In such a broad category of roofing, it makes sense that some asphalt roof shingles brands would work to break the age-old shingle mold. That’s where architectural shingles and other premium materials come into play. These thicker, heavier products offer a significantly improved defense against heavy winds and hailstone impact trauma. However, you can expect architectural shingles to run up to 40% more in material costs alone.

Are architectural shingles worth the extra cost? Most homeowners would say yes. This premium roof solution generally last much longer (at least 10 years more) than your typical three-tab shingles. They suffer fewer incidents of serious damage or displacement, making them easier to maintain. If you’re tired of calling out your local roofer for leak detection, consider one of these upgraded solutions.

Of course, you might consider a synthetic shingle, but that’s an entirely different league of premium roofing.

Asphalt Roof Shingles vs Metal

Which is better: a metal roof or shingles?” This opens up an entirely different topic of conversion, but so many people ask the question that it’s worth a short discussion. Excluding synthetics, shingles will almost always run cheaper than quality metal. With that being said, metal roofing outmatches asphalt shingles in almost every other point comparison.

  • Metal roofing (steel or aluminum) easily lasts up to 60 years or more.
  • Metal roof maintenance requires re-coating every ten years & little else.
  • Reflective characteristics make metal remarkably energy-efficient.
  • Heavy winds and hail strikes do little to damage sturdy metal panels.

Does the color of roof shingles make a difference? Yes and no. Brighter shingles will reflect more light (lowering your energy bill), but they will also cost more and fade over time. If you have the budget and inclination for a metal roof, most professionals would recommend switching to the more durable solution.

Which Roof Solution is Best for Me?

Examine your family budget. Take a look at the other roofs within your neighborhood. Consider how long you want to live inside your current home. Weigh these factors, and (no matter what the answer) you’ll likely eliminate over half of the solutions available on the market. Here’s a simple, short-handed guide on selecting your next roof replacement.

  • Short-Term, Low Budget: asphalt roof shingles
  • Mid-Term, Moderate Budget: architectural shingles (w/ high impact resistance)
  • Long-Term, Mid-High Budget: corrugated metal, synthetic shingles
  • Long-Term, High Budget: standing-seam metal, tile, slate
A Roofing Professional Nails New Shingles on a Roof

Find Your Roof Installation Estimate!

With so many solutions available on the market, finding a suitable material for your home may feel like a dizzying enterprise. Our team at Expert Roofing would like to make it easy for you! Using your budget and functional roofing requirements, we’ll supply you with a number exciting possibilities so that you can make an informed decision!

From the latest CertainTeed asphalt roof shingles in Crystal Lake and Schaumburg, IL, to old dependable metal systems, we support all kinds of solutions. Call our local office at (877) 766-3341 and discover the possibilities! We can’t wait to serve you.